信噪比在AR模型定阶方法选择中的研究

Abstract

Abstract:

There are many methods can be used to determine the order of AR models. For specific time series, different method may provide different results. How to select method adaptively for particular series is an important problem, especially in big data era. In this paper, we introduce a method to estimate the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the AR model in low-order noisy environments. It takes the influence of noise standard deviation, series length and eigenvalue of the model into consideration, which can be used as a criterion to evaluate the accuracy of AIC, BIC and FPE. The experimental results show that when the eigenvalue satisfies|λ₁|=|λ₂|=…=|λ_p|=|λ_max|, the order determination accuracy reaches the maximum under the condition of maximum eigenvalue. The accuracy is positively correlated with the series length and the distance of eigenvalue from origin, independent of noise standard deviation. Finally, based on the experimental results, we can select the order determination method of AR model according to the SNR of converted reference model, which provides a new perspective on the comparison of the advantages and disadvantages in different order determination methods.

Key words: Autoregressive model, Signal-to-noise ratio, Noise standard deviation, Series length, Eigenvalue, Reference model

CLC Number:

O212.1

Zhigang Wang,Yiming Ding. Research on Signal-to-Noise Ratio in Order Selection of AR Model[J].Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2020, 40(3): 811-823.

Trendmd

Figures/Tables 18

References 9

1	Subasi A , Alkan A , Koklukaya E , et al. Wavelet neural network classification of EEG signals by using AR model with MLE preprocessing. Neural Networks, 2005, 18 (7): 985- 997 doi: 10.1016/j.neunet.2005.01.006
2	Yin Y , Shang P . Forecasting traffic time series with multivariate predicting method. Applied Mathematics and Computation, 2016, 291, 266- 278 doi: 10.1016/j.amc.2016.07.017
3	Khorshidi S , Karimi M , Nematollahi A R . New autoregressive (AR) order selection criteria based on the prediction error estimation. Signal Processing, 2011, 91 (10): 2359- 2370 doi: 10.1016/j.sigpro.2011.04.021
4	刘源, 尹慧萍, 朱建平. 基于随机抽取的AR模型定阶和参数评估. 统计与决策, 2016, 24, 16- 18
5	Box G E P , Jenkins G M , Reinsel G C , et al. Time Series Analysis:Forecasting and Control. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, 2015
6	Fan J , Yao Q . Nonlinear Time Series:Nonparametric and Parametric Methods. New York: Springer Science & Business Media, 2008
7	Gooijer J G , Abraham B , Gould A , et al. Methods for determining the order of an autoregressive-moving average process:A survey. International Statistical Review, 1985, 53 (3): 301- 329 doi: 10.2307/1402894
8	Koehler A B , Murphree E S . A comparison of the Akaike and Schwarz criteria for selecting model order. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 1988, 37 (2): 187- 195
9	Bai D P , Wan Q , Guo X S , et al. Parametric SNR estimation based on auto-regressive model in AWGN channels. Journal of Electronic Science and Technology, 2008, 6 (1): 21- 24

序列长度	$\lambda_{\max }=0.4$		$\lambda_{\max }=0.5$		$\lambda_{\max }=0.6$
	准确率(%)	信噪比	准确率(%)	信噪比	准确率(%)	信噪比
300	62.0	36.831	88.4	38.611	90.5	41.012
400	73.8	36.838	90.6	38.627	91.2	41.038
500	81.5	36.842	90.8	38.642	91.1	41.064
600	85.2	36.862	91.3	38.648	90.8	41.072
700	87.6	36.864	91.3	38.656	91.0	41.078

序列长度	$\lambda_{\max }=0.4$		$\lambda_{\max }=0.5$		$\lambda_{\max }=0.6$
	准确率(%)	信噪比	准确率(%)	信噪比	准确率(%)	信噪比
300	18.0	36.831	73.5	38.611	99.4	41.012
400	27.6	36.838	88.9	38.627	99.9	41.038
500	38.6	36.842	95.7	38.642	100.0	41.064
600	50.2	36.862	98.4	38.648	100.0	41.072
700	60.9	36.864	99.5	38.656	100.0	41.078

准确度	AR(2)		AR(3)		AR(4)		AR(5)
	上界	下界	上界	下界	上界	下界	上界	下界
$F>A>B$	$33.9_{0.0}$	$37.4_{29.1}$	$33.9_{0.0}$	$47.8_{32.4}$	$33.9_{0.0}$	$57.9_{25.4}$	$33.9_{0.0}$	$78.6_{31.9}$
$A>F>B$	$37.4_{29.1}$	$40.7_{73.0}$	$47.8_{32.4}$	$54.2_{71.0}$	$57.9_{25.4}$	$71.0_{71.5}$	$78.6_{31.9}$	$92.6_{69.3}$
$A>B>F$	$40.7_{73.0}$	$44.1_{88.5}$	$54.2_{71.0}$	$62.1_{88.2}$	$71.0_{71.5}$	$82.1_{88.6}$	$92.6_{69.3}$	$108.1_{86.0}$
$B>A>F$	$44.1_{88.5}$	$63.4_{99.1}$	$62.1_{88.2}$	$85.5_{99.3}$	$82.1_{88.6}$	$107.8_{99.2}$	$108.1_{86.0}$	$129.6_{99.9}$

准确率	AR(2)		AR(3)		AR(4)		AR(5)
	上界	下界	上界	下界	上界	下界	上界	下界
$F>A>B$	$33.9_{0.0}$	$36.1_{27.9}$	$33.9_{0.0}$	$43.7_{30.1}$	$34.0_{0.0}$	$55.3_{33.4}$	$34.1_{0.0}$	$70.8_{36.7}$
$A>F>B$	$36.1_{27.9}$	$38.6_{83.7}$	$43.7_{30.1}$	$49.2_{78.6}$	$55.3_{33.4}$	$64.0_{79.2}$	$70.8_{36.7}$	$83.3_{82.2}$
$A>B>F$	$38.6_{83.7}$	$40.8_{90.0}$	$49.2_{78.6}$	$54.1_{89.9}$	$64.0_{79.2}$	$71.6_{90.2}$	$83.3_{82.2}$	$94.0_{90.9}$
$B>A>F$	$40.8_{90.0}$	$52.0_{99.5}$	$54.1_{89.9}$	$89.5_{100.0}$	$71.6_{90.2}$	$113.7_{99.7}$	$94.0_{90.9}$	$137.8_{99.9}$

准确率	AR(2)		AR(3)		AR(4)		AR(5)
	上界	下界	上界	下界	上界	下界	上界	下界
$F>A>B$	$34.0_{0.0}$	$35.5_{34.5}$	$34.0_{0.0}$	$41.4_{33.6}$	$34.1_{0.0}$	$51.0_{34.7}$	$34.1_{0.0}$	$64.8_{38.4}$
$A>F>B$	$35.5_{34.5}$	$37.2_{84.1}$	$41.4_{33.6}$	$46.1_{86.2}$	$51.0_{34.7}$	$58.8_{86.3}$	$64.8_{38.4}$	$74.7_{85.1}$
$A>B>F$	$37.2_{84.1}$	$38.5_{92.0}$	$46.1_{86.2}$	$49.0_{90.7}$	$58.8_{86.3}$	$63.1_{91.4}$	$74.7_{85.1}$	$80.8_{92.8}$
$B>A>F$	$38.5_{92.0}$	$66.4_{99.5}$	$49.0_{90.7}$	$90.8_{100.0}$	$63.1_{91.4}$	$115.6_{99.9}$	$80.8_{92.8}$	$140.8_{100.0}$

Research on Signal-to-Noise Ratio in Order Selection of AR Model

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 18

References 9

Related Articles 15

Metrics

Comments

Recommended 10

阶数	$SNR$	推荐方法	准确率1	准确率2
3	61.9	$BIC$	100%	100%
4	75.0	$BIC$	100%	100%
5	88.3	$BIC$	100%	100%

[1]	Yang Guicheng, Wen Yangzhe, Mao Jing. A Universal Inequality for the Dirichlet Eigenvalue Problem of the Weighted Laplacian and its Application [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2025, 45(1): 54-73.
[2]	Liu Wei, Xu Meizhen. Eigenvalues of a Class of Second-Order Differential Operator with Eigenparameters Dependent Internal Point Conditions [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2024, 44(4): 815-828.
[3]	Hu Wenyu, Xu Weiru, Zeng Yu. An Inverse Eigenvalue Problem for a Kind of Periodic Pseudo-Jacobi Matrix [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2024, 44(3): 761-770.
[4]	He Ya, An Jing. An Effective Fourier Spectral Approximation for Fourth-Order Eigenvalue Problems with Periodic Boundary Conditions [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2024, 44(1): 37-49.
[5]	Liu Xiaoyun,Shi Guoliang,Yan Jun. The Multiplicities of Eigenvalues and Inverse Nodal Problem of a Vectorial Sturm-Liouville Problem [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2023, 43(3): 669-679.
[6]	He Yue, Ruan Qihua. Refined Lower Bound for Sums of Eigenvalues of the Laplace Operator [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2023, 43(1): 14-26.
[7]	Kang Sun,Yunlan Gao. A Class of Differential Operators with Eigenparameter Dependent Boundary Conditions [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2022, 42(3): 661-670.
[8]	Haixiong Li,Xinlin Wu,Daoxin Ding. Multiple Spectra of Self-Similar Measures with Three Digits [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2022, 42(3): 705-715.
[9]	Hongxing Wu,Dengbin Yuan,Shenghua Wang. Asymptotic Stability Analysis of Solutions to Transport Equations in Structured Bacterial Population Growth [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2022, 42(3): 807-817.
[10]	Wenwen Yan,Meizhen Xu. The Self-Adjointness and Dependence of Eigenvalues of Fourth-Order Differential Operator with Eigenparameters in the Boundary Conditions [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2022, 42(3): 671-693.
[11]	Yingchun Zhao,Jiong Sun,Siqin Yao, Burenmandula. Non-Real Eigenvalues of a Class of Indefinite Sturm-Liouville Operators with Discontinuity at Interior Points [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2021, 41(6): 1643-1656.
[12]	Min Fu,Jiajun Hao,Liejun Xie,Jinping Wang. Exact Support Recovery of Sparse Signals from Noisy Measurements [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2021, 41(5): 1555-1565.
[13]	Jingran He,Helin Guo,Wenqing Wang. A p-Laplace Eigenvalue Problem with Coercive Potentials [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2021, 41(5): 1323-1332.
[14]	Dan Wang,Mengkun Zhu,Chen Yang,Xiaoli Wang. A Generalised Decic Freud-Type Weight [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2021, 41(4): 921-935.
[15]	Yue He,Hailong Her. An Estimate of Spectral Gap for Schrödinger Operators on Compact Manifolds [J]. Acta mathematica scientia,Series A, 2020, 40(2): 257-270.